Birnam Wood

Spoilers for the whole of Birnam Wood

Birnam Wood Book Review by Eleanor Catton

This book really surprised me.

Once again, I read this for my husband’s family’s annual Thanksgiving book club. I should have had more faith in it from the start, since his cousin picked it this time instead of his dad (sorry, Jonathan), and his cousin has pretty good taste in books.

Still, I’m often doubtful of other people’s opinions on what makes a good book. And then, bam! Here came Birnam Wood.

First of all, it’s described as an eco-political thriller, which is just insane. In my 32 years of life, I don’t think I’ve ever read a book with those genre tags, and that’s saying something, because I’ve read a lot of books.

Birnam Wood is set in New Zealand and follows a guerrilla gardening collective, also called Birnam Wood, that plants crops on unused land, whether or not anyone gave them permission. It’s run by Mira Bunting, its idealistic founder, and her best friend and right hand, Shelley.

When a landslide closes off a mountain pass and isolates the town of Thorndike, Mira sees an opportunity: an abandoned farm owned by Sir Owen Darvish and his wife, Lady Jill Darvish, that’s perfect for Birnam Wood to take over.

But the farm already has an interested buyer: Robert Lemoine, a cocky American billionaire who claims he wants to build a doomsday bunker there.

Lemoine offers to fund Birnam Wood. Mira is tempted. And on top of all that, Tony, an old flame of Mira’s, suddenly reappears back in town with a chip on his shoulder and a nose for a story.

Before I get into it, a fair warning: this book is dense.

When I first started reading it, I fell asleep multiple times, sometimes in the middle of the day, which is unusual and would normally spell disaster for a book. In this case, I’ll chalk it up to pregnancy exhaustion and dense writing instead.

Because the first half of the book, and I mean literally the first half, is just Catton delving into her characters’ psyches and backgrounds. That’s all of it.

She delves into Mira’s background, how she started Birnam Wood, her relationship with Shelley, and how she feels about her parents’ divorce. Then you get Shelley’s POV: how she wants to leave Birnam Wood, and how she’s felt second best her whole life, like the side character, especially next to Mira.

She’s done all the hard work for Birnam Wood and gotten none of the credit. She wants out, and she plans to sleep with Tony when he reappears, which misfires horribly.

Then you get Tony’s POV: his love for Mira, his thoughts on politics, on being a Kiwi, on monogamy versus polygamy.

And then you get Robert Lemoine. He microdoses on acid, has security teams and whole scales of people at his disposal, and thinks he can outsmart everyone.

He’s using the bunker on the Darvishes’ land as a front to mine a New Zealand national park for precious minerals. You learn that he caused the landslide that killed five people and that he doesn’t really care. He’s smart, he’s cruel, and to him, everyone is a tool.

You even get POVs from the Darvishes, which were fascinating, especially Lady Darvish, who seems to both resent her husband and miss him dearly once he’s gone.

Every character in this book is heavily fleshed out, almost too much, actually, and almost all in one go.

After the slow slog of that first half, where literally two events happen (Tony comes back and they hold the hui about Robert’s offer), I was like, damn. NOTHING is happening in this book.

Then I realized Catton was just setting up the second half, which was like dominoes falling one after the other after the other.

Spoiler warning from here on out, as I’ll be discussing the second half and the ending in detail.

Suddenly, all of Birnam Wood is in Thorndike. Mira is striking a deal with Robert and also wants to sleep with him. Shelley is more jealous than ever. The Darvishes know something is up. And then shit hits the fan so fast and so crazily that I was left spinning.

I didn’t think this book had it in it. I really didn’t.

I loved it. I loved the drama, the cat-and-mouse of everyone filling in the pieces, and the dramatic irony of the reader knowing exactly where everyone stands while the characters themselves don’t.

I couldn’t believe Shelley slept with Robert, or that she ends up killing Sir Owen while on acid. I couldn’t believe Tony had as much grit as he did, or that Mira was all bark and no bite at the end of the day, falling under Robert’s spell.

That’s what all that groundwork in the first half buys you: by the time the dominoes start falling, you know these people so well that every betrayal and every bad decision lands.

Each character had so much to offer.

Which brings me to my biggest complaint: the ending.

I HATE ambiguous endings. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: if I’m reading your 400+ page book, I want an ending. I don’t want to guess. I don’t want to insinuate. I want you to tell me.

And Catton doesn’t. Not really.

I needed ten more pages. Hell, I would have taken three. Just enough to see if anyone found Tony, and what the media made of all these people from Birnam Wood covered in puke. Did Mira and the others die? Did Shelley?

I’m glad Robert died, and at the hands of Lady Darvish to boot. But what about the guard who shot Lady Darvish? Too much was left in the air and unsaid, and it drives me NUTS.

You spend half a book setting up these incredibly detailed characters, I fall for every single one of them, and then you don’t tell me what happens to them? Urgh.

Another thing I’ll mention is just how smart this book felt to me. The vocabulary, the syntax, the conversations about economics, love, and politics were fantastic, especially after reading some other books that were definitely not as smart as I wanted them to be. I truly admire Catton and her writing for that.

As for the pacing, with the first half as a psychological profile of each character and the second half as an action-driven thriller, I liked it because I wasn’t expecting it and I’d never read anything quite like it. I always like novel.

But I don’t think I’d want every book to be this way. One Birnam Wood is enough. If every book I picked up took two hundred pages to get going, I’d never finish anything (and I’d fall asleep a lot more).

Overall, I enjoyed this book quite a bit. It took its sweet time, but once it got going, it didn’t let go. And if it weren’t for that maddening ending, it might have been even higher.

Recommendation: If you’re patient enough to push through a slow, dense first half, Birnam Wood will reward you with one of the most explosive second halves I’ve read in a long time.

If you need your books to move from page one, or you can’t stand ambiguous endings (like me), go in prepared. And maybe trust your book club a little more than I did.

Score: 8/10 (would have been higher with a real ending)

 
Next
Next

The Ministry of Time